Faves for this Web page

  • darrellp - Dec 16 2008 | cars ergonomics

    The lame reason that automakers moved the dimmer switch from the floor to the steering column. I've wondered for a long time why they would move it from the floor where it was operated with a left foot that has nothing else to do (at least in an automatic) to a steering column where your hand is involved in the rather important job of STEERING THE CAR!!!

    • royleban - Dec 16 2008

      I disagree with this post. In every car I've owned, I haven't had to remove my hand from the wheel to activate a stalk-mounted dimmer. I think it's safer than the floor switch and the foot brake is one reason.

    • darrellp - Dec 18 2008

      The fact that you have to do anything other than steer is a bad thing in my opinion, especially when your foot is down there doing nothing at all. With no disrespect, I'm just curious whether you've driven with a foot dimmer switch? I found it a much better way of handling things.

    • royleban - Dec 19 2008

      Yes, of course, I've driven with a foot dimmer switch. My first car was a 1964 Chevy Belair, back when those cars used to be decent. My second car was a 1971 Belair, also with a foot switch. I can't recall the configuration of the two cars followed (Dodge Colt, VW Rabbit), but I know the cars after that (Hondas, plus one Acura and a Toyota) all had stalk mounted bright controls.

      First off, on a manual transmission car, I think having another use for either foot is just a bad idea. But, even on an automatic, I think using the hand is fine. It's not like you should be switching your brights on and off all the time -- basically, you should never be in a rush to turn them on and sometimes you might be in a rush to turn them off.

      If you want really stupid, consider the 1979 Ford Futura where they moved the horn to the end of the turn signal stalk. Rather than hitting the middle of the steering wheel or maybe even pushing buttons with your thumbs, you had to push in the end of the turn signal stalk to honk the horn. You could only do it with your left hand and only with your fingertips while holding the wheel. Dumb!

Add a Fave for this Web page

What happens when I press Publish?
Your Fave for this Web page gets shared with the Faves community. You can access it at any time by selecting "My Faves" from the menu above.
Why do you ask for my email address?
We use your email address to create an account, so you can easily find your Fave again at a later time.
Rate It

Separate each email address with a comma.
WE DO NOT SPAM | Please read our privacy policy.