Faves for this Web page

  • mike - Dec 14 2007 | drm, legal, piracy, kindle, amazon

    I disagree with the author here. I think Amazon strikes a good balance for this v1 product. Unlike iTunes, digital media purchased on Amazon is stored in your account on their servers. If you lose your device in the future, you can download books from your library for free to a replacement device - in perpetuity (in contrast, if you lose an iTunes dowloaded song - Apple says "tough luck" - and you have to buy it again).

    Amazon DOES support a minimum level of sharing of media - I have multiple Kindles in my account (for different family members). Since they are all part of our family's library, any one in our family can download these media to their Kindle to read.

    I agree, it would be better to have an ability to transfer media to another user (delete from my devices and library, and add to someone else's). 20 years hence, I would imagine that my online digital library at Amazon will be itself quite a valuable personal asset. When I die, do I get to pass that on to my heirs? Can I sell my account to another person?

    Once lawmakers understand how much is at stake for individuals (thousands of dollars of digital assets per person), I would hope they will be compelled to enact legislation protecting our investments.

    • jacoxnet - Jan 01 2008

      It's fine as long as you trust Amazon and as long as Amazon continues with that business model. A few years ago, I bought several ebooks from Amazon, which at the time was using the Adobe encrypted ebook drm. Amazon maintained your "digital library" online, where you were free to re-download these items if you happened to need to do that, as you sometimes did if you wanted to move the books to another computer. One day, I guess their business model changed (probably in anticipation of the Kindle) and the ebook functionality simply disappeared from Amazon. There was no way to re-download the books anymore. I have them now on an old laptop, but there is no way I know of to move them to any other computer.

    • mike - Jan 02 2008

      Well, that sucks. It does seem odd that their is not an integrated eBook offering on Amazon - you should be able to purchase any ebook, and then download to multiple readers (Sony's, Kindle, PC).

  • derek - Dec 14 2007 | drm, books, blogs, amazon, kindle

    Ugh. When will the disastrous, failed DRM experiment end?

Votes for this web page

Add a Fave for this Web page

What happens when I press Publish?
Your Fave for this Web page gets shared with the Faves community. You can access it at any time by selecting "My Faves" from the menu above.
Why do you ask for my email address?
We use your email address to create an account, so you can easily find your Fave again at a later time.
Rate It

Separate each email address with a comma.
WE DO NOT SPAM | Please read our privacy policy.

Related Content from Around Faves

amazon

VIEW ALL