Permalink
Mike on nader
  • vote
    4
    0 starsmike | Shared With: Everyone - Jan 24 2008 | nader, safety, airbags, economics
    John Graham Releases Results of Cost-Benefit Analysis of Air Bag Safety

    Harvard Center for Risk Analysis did a cost-benefit analysis of airbags. Despite the fact that the public overwhelmingly believes airbags to be a safe and cost-effective enhancement to a modern vehicle, this study found that driver's side airbags cost $70,000 per "year of life saved" and passenger side airbags cost $400,000 per year of life saved.

    The latter figure is one that obviously is not one that could be economically justified for the general population. Even for the driver's side airbag, I think the cost seems to be much higher than other life-saving expenditures we can be making.

    Why did Nader believe so strongly that air bags needed to be installed in cars? It seems irrational to me. At this point, I think his ego is so tied up with airbags that he would never come out against them no matter how detrimental or expensive they turn out to be.

    Quoted: air bags kill more children than they save according to the "best available evidence,"

  • vote
    3
    0 starsmike | Shared With: Everyone - Jan 24 2008 | movies, documentary, nader, safety, politics
    Netflix: Ralph Nader: An Unreasonable Man

    Really good video about Ralph Nader. He was thrust into national prominence after GM tried to smear his character through "dirty tricks" - which all came out in congressional hearings. Nader assumed the mantel of "white knight" and became very powerful.

    No product can be made completely safe - but the cars built before 1965 paid little attention to passenger safety. Is there a point at which we can say that government is overstepping it's role and actually causing more harm than good in the regulation of an industry? I've long held a suspicion that the wide deployment of airbags has been a net harm to the American consumer rather than a needed safety feature (air bags largely are there to protect people who DON'T use safety belts).

1 - 2 of 2 Faves

Related Content from Around Faves

safety

VIEW ALL

documentaries

VIEW ALL