• vote
    6
    0 starsmohit | Shared With: Everyone - Nov 22 2008 | google, community, search, technology
    Google, It Wasn’t Broke

    I do think search + community could work together well (duh). However, I think some aspects of Google's implementation are confusing. And, I'm surprised Google didn't launch it as an experimental feature first.

    Specific complaints:
    1) Promote/Remove: I don't really get the value. If there is value, it is certainly not immediately obvious. Does promoting it just affect me, or does it affect everybody? What if I click remove, and the underlying page changes to the point that it now might be valuable? I just want Google to do the right thing without me having to train it.
    2) I have a "Note This" and "Comment" links at the bottom of my search results. That "feels" a little redundant.

    Also, I wonder why Google just didn't keep the Star/Share metaphors that they use on their other products.

    Quoted: Bucket tests and experimental products are one thing. But to mess with the real Google search is serious stuff. Why did they do ...

    Showing 1 - 1 of 1 comments
    • sung - Nov 22 2008

      i dinked around with the 'promote / remove' feature as well. felt that the remove feature did the opposite of what i felt it should. i would remove a search results and it would appear at the bottom more prominently asking me if i really wanted to remove these items. so instead of removing / demoting these search results they actually made me take a closer look at them.

    You must be Mohit's friend before you can comment on this Fave.
    Send Mohit a friend request or a personal message instead.

Related Faves from mohit